Doctor Who – The Talons of Weng-Chiang. Episode Two

talons 02.jpg

Although we learnt in episode one that the Tong of the Black Scorpion (“fanatical followers of an ancient Chinese god called Weng-Chiang”) seem to be involved in this devilish business, it now becomes clear that Chang is merely a subordinate character and his master – Weng-Chiang (or at least someone masquerading as him) – is the one directing events.

Weng-Chiang, or Magnus Greel to give him his real name, lives beneath the Palace Theatre.  Why he should do this – unless he’s a devotee of The Phantom of the Opera – is never made clear.  But since Chang is performing at the theatre it makes some sort of sense that Greel is close at hand – especially since Chang has been abducting girls off the street for him.

The science-fiction elements of the story now begin be pulled together as we learn that Greel is a refugee, afraid of the intervention of time-agents.  Why he wants the girls is also explained (“the disease grows worse. Each distillation lasts less than the time before”) and that until he recovers the Time Cabinet he’ll never be whole again.

It’s a remarkable coincidence that the Time Cabinet is in Lifefoot’s possession.  He’s unaware of its significance, regarding it as little more than a Chinese curio, although we’ll learn more about this in episode three.

For those who worry about such things, then the timeline of this story is very odd.  If Litefoot’s had the cabinet for decades, what has Greel been doing all this time?  We see that his body is in collapse, with only the life-essence from young female donors keeping him alive, so how has be survived during this period?  He can’t have been in London for more than a few weeks (based on the number of girls abducted) so are we really supposed to believe he’s only just decided that reclaiming the Time Cabinet might be a good idea?  And since Litefoot’s father was a notable member of the British government in China, surely it wouldn’t have been too difficult to work out that his family was the one gifted the Time Cabinet ….

Episode two sees the Doctor encounter Jago for the first time.  There’s a characteristic gear-change from the Doctor – to begin with he’s jovial – pretending to be a music-hall act ( “dramatic recitations, singing, tap-dancing. I can play the Trumpet Voluntary in a bowl of live goldfish”) – but in a double-heartbeat he turns serious.  As touched upon before, Tom could do this better than anyone and both he and Benjamin make these scenes – largely expository ones – sparkle.

Another signature moment occurs when Leela and Litefoot enjoy a bite to eat, with Leela’s table-manners being somewhat lacking.  Litefoot, the perfect host, elects to copy his guest in order not to make her feel awkward, which gives Trevor Baxter another nice character moment.

4 thoughts on “Doctor Who – The Talons of Weng-Chiang. Episode Two

  1. At a guess Magnus Greel was ok from at first from the effects of the time cabinet and then slowly started getting ill… it seems unlikely that he bought the distillation chamber from the 52nd Century and must have built it while in the 19th Century. The novelisation expands upon how Greel is getting Chang to scan areas of the capitol area by area.


    • He may have built the distillation chamber in the 19th Century but the implication given is that his illness was triggered when he used the Time Cabinet to flee from his enemies in the 51st Century.

      DOCTOR: The Zigma experiments came to nothing. They were a failure. Nothing came of them.
      WENG-CHIANG: No! No, they were a success! Why, I used them to escape from my enemies. The first man to travel through time.
      DOCTOR: Hmm. Look what it did to you.
      WENG-CHIANG: A temporal distortion of my metabolism. It can be readjusted.

      I guess you could argue that it was only in the last few months prior to the events on screen that he really began to weaken, but that leaves at least fifteen years unaccounted for (Litefoot mentions that their family came home in 1873 with the Time Cabinet and since Jack the Ripper is mentioned, Talons has to be set during 1888 or later).

      Chang does say that he nursed Greel back to life when he first appeared, so some of this time is accounted for, but it still leaves a fair period when he seems to have done very little (and you’d have assumed that regaining the Time Cabinet would have been his top priority). But given the speed Holmes had to write the script, it’s understandable there’s a few logical flaws (and I daresay someone, somewhere has attempted to write a story to fill this gap!)


      • Oh I didn’t doubt it was the Zygma Experiment which caused the illness. Chang said the soliders of the Emperor took the cabinet. It is likely that Greel took a long time to recover and it may well have been that he and Chang found out a lot later that the cabinet had been given as a gift. We also need to account for the journey time it took Greel and Chang to get to England. Baring in mind that Greel may well have been sick while traveling. Alternatively his priority to get the cabinet was triggered by his collapse. It is also possible that he was using the machine less frequently before and the disappearance of the 9 girls in close proximity has alterted the police

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s